Wyeth, plaintiff dispute dismissal request
- April
- 23
A reasonable person who was subjected to the racist taunts that a Wyeth Pharmaceuticals Inc. scientist endured would have felt the workplace was hostile, a lawyer for the scientist argues in court papers.
The lawyer, Steven Morelli, is trying to convince U.S. District Court Judge Charles L. Brieant to let the lawsuit filed by Mellard Jennings go to trial.
Wyeth’s lawyers filed papers in February and again this week urging Brieant, who works out of White Plains, to dismiss the lawsuit.
Jennings, 52, sued the company and fellow scientist Charles Guinosso in January 2007, alleging that Guinosso called him “boy,” and taunted him by making fun of Aunt Jemima and acting out a routine from “Amos ‘N Andy,” a defunct radio and television show that characterized blacks in an offensive way.
Jennings, a resident of Highland Falls, is black, while Guinosso is white. Both work at the company’s Pearl River campus.
In the company’s latest filing, Wyeth’s lawyers — who also represent Guinosso — argue that Jennings “raises baseless arguments and asserts irrelevant or unfounded facts in a desperate attempt to stave off” dismissal of his lawsuit.
Wyeth says Jennings has not met the legal standard for showing that he faced a hostile work environment because he has not shown Guinosso’s actions and comments were “either severe or pervasive.” The company says it has presented examples of other court cases involving allegations of harassment that were dismissed even though the allegations were more severe than the ones Jennings has made.
Jennings has also not shown the Guinosso’s conduct interfered with his ability to do his job, the company argues. Wyeth took action against Guinosso for his behavior and never retaliated against Jennings for bringing it to management’s attention, the company argues, disputing claims Jennings has made.
Jennings is one of seven black current and former employees of Wyeth’s Pearl River operations who sued the company for alleged race discrimination.
The company has so far succeeded in defeating two of the lawsuits. A jury ruled in the company’s favor in one suit and a judge dismissed another, leaving five suits, including the one filed by Jennings.









